Browse all questions

What is the difference between a scripture translation and a commentary?

हिन्दी

A translation aims to express the meaning of a text in another language while remaining accountable to the specific source wording. A commentary explains or interprets the text, often adding doctrinal reasoning, alternative readings, historical context or a named teacher's understanding. A separate reader-friendly explanation can clarify unfamiliar concepts without claiming to be a literal translation or an inherited traditional commentary.

For example, translating one Sanskrit term as “Self” is a translational decision; explaining what a particular Shaiva or Advaita school understands by that term belongs to interpretation. Different translations may be defensible, but they are not automatically interchangeable witnesses. ShivGoraksh must present Sanskrit source, Hindi translation, English translation, explanation and any attributed historical commentary as separate layers, each with appropriate provenance, rights and review status. No AI paraphrase should be labelled a traditional commentary.

References & Sources

These references accompany the original answer. Independent source and specialist verification remain incomplete.

  1. What is a critical edition—and why should you care?
  2. Searching in Languages with Non-Roman Scripts
About these answers

Initial public editorial edition. Independent source, textual, rights and specialist reviews remain incomplete. These answers introduce their subjects; they are not certified ritual instructions.

Editorial policy